Healthcare payers are increasingly focused on preventing payment errors before they occur. Yet many payment integrity programs still rely heavily on downstream interventions, and success continues to be measured by the errors identified, the claims denied, and the dollars recovered. What if health plans could prevent more medical billing errors and improve payment accuracy by rethinking when and how they engage providers?
During Codoxo’s recent AI for PI Summit, Dr. Priscilla Alfaro, a physician and strategic advisor on healthcare cost containment and payment transformation, challenged the “us vs. them” mindset that can shape payer-provider relationships. Her message to payment integrity leaders? Start by understanding why billing errors and overpayments occur, make fuller use of provider education programs with the help of AI, and rethink how success is measured when improper payments are prevented rather than denied or recovered.
Does Every Billing Error Need to Become a Denial?
Alfaro offers a simple principle for approaching provider billing errors: “Don’t assume guilt.” From a physician’s perspective, the payment integrity process can sometimes feel adversarial, particularly when unintentional billing inaccuracies lead to claim denials and additional administrative work. Providers must navigate changing coding requirements and reimbursement policies across multiple health plans, making transparency, communication, and a strong payer-provider partnership especially important.
Some of these interventions could be described as “gotcha edits” vs. fraud, waste, and abuse (FWA) – a healthcare claim is denied for an issue the provider can correct, only to be resubmitted and ultimately paid. When denied claims are eventually paid anyway, both organizations have created additional work without necessarily improving billing accuracy on future claims. According to Alfaro, there is a better way.
Make Provider Education Specific Enough to Change Behavior
Provider education has long been part of payment integrity services, but AI-powered analytics offer opportunities to make these programs more effective across the claims lifecycle. By identifying recurring billing patterns and the healthcare providers most affected, health plans can tailor education to specific issues rather than relying on broad communications.
Effective provider education starts with understanding the differences between physician practices. A provider’s specialty and patient population can influence medical billing patterns, while provider contract terms and reimbursement policies determine which requirements apply. AI-powered analysis of provider-specific billing activity can help health plans build a clearer picture of the provider, helping to then accurately identify emerging coding and billing issues and determine where targeted education may be an appropriate first intervention.
The opportunity also extends beyond professional claims. Outpatient facility billing is another area where targeted education may be particularly valuable, especially when relatively small reimbursement differences make individual claims adjustments less practical.
Even targeted education can create confusion when the message isn’t clear. Alfaro shared an example involving emergency physicians who objected to a reimbursement communication because they believed it applied to their professional claims. The notice referenced a revenue code, indicating that the policy actually concerned facility claims. Clarifying that distinction resolved the misunderstanding.
The Real Test: Did Provider Behavior Actually Change?
The success of provider education should ultimately be measured by whether billing behavior changes, not how many letters are sent or notifications delivered. But a lack of improvement doesn’t necessarily mean a provider has disregarded the guidance. Sometimes the communication never reaches the right person or isn’t read at all. Health plans need to understand whether providers received and engaged with the information.
Alfaro suggested allowing approximately three months to begin evaluating changes in billing behavior, with a defined follow-up process when improvement does not occur. Education should provide an opportunity to correct a problem, but it cannot become an indefinite substitute for action. AI-powered analytics can help health plans track these changes across providers, identify where additional intervention is warranted, and refine future education efforts.
What If the Best Payment Integrity Outcome Never Shows Up in Your Savings Report?
Traditional payment integrity programs have established ways to measure savings from claim reductions and recoveries. When education changes provider behavior and an inaccurate claim is never submitted, however, there is no denied claim or recovery amount to record. Comparing and benchmarking provider cohorts, along with tracking claims activity over time can help health plans distinguish the impact of education from other changes in billing behavior. But measurement methodology is only part of the challenge.
Another lies in how payment integrity and Special Investigation Unit (SIU) teams are evaluated. Performance metrics often emphasize dollars saved, cases opened, or providers placed on prepay review. When teams are rewarded primarily for downstream interventions, successful prevention may be less visible in their performance results, even as organizations seek to prevent payment errors earlier in the process.
A more complete assessment of payment integrity performance should account for sustained improvements in billing accuracy and the operational costs avoided when unnecessary denials and disputes decline. Establishing credible measures of preventive savings will require collaboration with finance and other organizational leaders, particularly if these programs are to receive the same investment and recognition as traditional payment integrity interventions.
Moving Provider Engagement Upstream
For payment integrity leaders looking to move beyond post-payment recoveries and traditional efforts to prevent overpayments, a practical starting point is to examine recurring billing errors and denials to identify opportunities for earlier intervention. Which issues could be addressed through targeted provider education before the next claim is submitted? And are current education efforts actually changing billing behavior, or simply generating more communications? The answers can help health plans reduce unnecessary denials and build a stronger case for recognizing prevention as a measurable payment integrity outcome. This approach can also help reduce provider abrasion, shifting payer-provider relationships away from an adversarial cycle of denials and corrections toward greater collaboration on billing accuracy.
To learn more about rethinking provider engagement and to view the full-length AI for PI Summit session, visit the AI for PI Community YouTube page.
